Restaurants Off The Beaten Path

Beyond Downtown - Hidden Gems to Chef’s Table Chic

Some of Isla’s best meals happen when you step away from the crowds and wander beyond the usual routes. Whether you’re cruising down a quiet backstreet or strolling into one of the island’s gorgeous resorts, this is where things get seriously tasty.

We’re talking family-run kitchens serving up recipes passed down for generations, open-air grills with catch-of-the-day perfection, and casual patios with plastic chairs and unforgettable dishes.

But don’t let the laid-back vibes fool you – Isla’s fine dining scene is definitely having a moment. Tucked between neighborhood homes with a discreet sign or hidden inside luxury resorts, you’ll find chef-driven restaurants where the menu and the wine list will absolutely blow you away.

Looking for a sunset dinner without the crowds? A waterfront lunch you’ll dream about later? A romantic meal where the dessert menu is as sweet as the company? You’ll find it here… off the beaten path, full of flavor, and totally worth the extra wander.

So come hungry and don’t wear anything too tight.

Some of Isla’s best meals happen when you step away from the crowds and wander beyond the usual routes. Whether you’re cruising down a quiet backstreet or strolling into one of the island’s gorgeous resorts, this is where things get seriously tasty.

We’re talking family-run kitchens serving up recipes passed down for generations, open-air grills with catch-of-the-day perfection, and casual patios with plastic chairs and unforgettable dishes.

But don’t let the laid-back vibes fool you – Isla’s fine dining scene is definitely having a moment. Tucked between neighborhood homes with a discreet sign or hidden inside luxury resorts, you’ll find chef-driven restaurants where the menu and the wine list will absolutely blow you away.

Looking for a sunset dinner without the crowds? A waterfront lunch you’ll dream about later? A romantic meal where the dessert menu is as sweet as the company? You’ll find it here… off the beaten path, full of flavor, and totally worth the extra wander.

So come hungry and don’t wear anything too tight.

Search Outside of Town Restaurants

Showing Island Eateries 1-21 of 29

La Justicia de Don Pino

Colonias – Mid-island
Step off the beaten path and savor seafood and history in Isla Mujeres’ local treasure.

El Charco Deisy & Raul

Colonias – Mid-island
Heartwarming home cooking in a cozy mid-island setting. Traditional Yucatecan food that’s simply unmissable!

El Chefcito

Colonias – Mid Island
A family-owned hidden gem, serving up authentic Mexican flavors and local delights, a true taste of Isla Mujeres.

Pizza Mike’s

Colonias – Mid-island
New York style pizzas, irresistible garlic knots, and lobster pizza to die for – prepare for Italian perfection!

Kash Keken Chuc

Colonias – Mid-island
Charcoal grilled love: Succulent chicken, pork, ribs and tortas at this bright pink mid-Island favorite.

Samura

Punta Sur – South End Bay Side
Step into an enchanting world where Japanese Asian delights and jungle magic unite, a culinary adventure like no other.

Mar-Bella Rawbar & Grill

Punta Sur – South End Bay Side
A seaside feast of fresh, raw delights and grilled wonders, where every bite is a piece of heaven.

Aurora Cocina & Bar

Colonias – Mid-island
Where culinary dreams come true, from tasty lunches to Happy Hour and mind-blowing dinners!

Lolo Lorena

Colonias – Mid-island
A hidden culinary jewel, serving fabulous set course dinners in a magical setting. Come for the food, stay for the memories.

Bastos Grill

Colonias – Mid-island
A hidden gem serving a delightful mix of Mexican and International dishes, with warm smiles and enticing flavors.

Oscar’s Grill

Colonias – Mid-island
Delicious pizza, addictive garlic knots, and chairs you just can’t ignore. For the picky eater or the food adventurer.

Caribbean Brisas

Colonias – Mid-island
Feast on tantalizing seafood, sip on divine drinks, and sway to lively music, while relaxing in the rhythms of Isla life.

Ice Bar

Sac Bajo Península
Beat the heat at the coolest spot on the island. A tropical igloo where your shot comes in an ice glass.

Fuego de Mar

Colonias – Mid Island
A masterpiece of presentation and a celebration of freshness that’ll have you yearning for just one more bite.

Soggy Peso

Colonias – Mid-island
Where strong margaritas meet stronger stories, under the canvas of a fiery sunset. A seaside shack full of character and cheers!

Rosa Sirena’s

Colonias – Mid-island
A lively blend of romance, fun, and delectable cuisine, where laughter is the main course.

Limón

Colonias – Mid Island
Fine dining meets fiery imagination in a romantic garden. Say ‘Yes, Chef!’ to Lobster Sergio style!

Greenverde

Colonias – Mid-island
Enjoy the fun, funky vibes, and savor Mexican delights that are as pleasing to the palate as they are to the pocket.

DeNuccio’s

Punta Sur – South End
Italian culinary bliss by the sea. Relish antipasto, homemade pastas, fine wines and turquoise vistas.

Sunset Grill

Colonias – Mid-island
Dreamy sunsets, divine European cuisine, and a magical waterfront setting that’s perfect for memorable celebrations.
Showing Island Eateries 1-21 of 29
Loading...