The best-kept secret on Isla Mujeres that locals and seasoned travelers swear by. Once known as Cockteleria Justicia Social and was situated near the downtown ferry dock, this fisherman’s co-op restaurant found its new home mid-island, near the Chedraui supermarket.

This isn’t just a place to grab a bite; it’s a chance to immerse yourself in Isla’s rich history. Adorned with photos of local baseball teams, some dating back decades, you’ll be dining amidst stories of the island’s vibrant past, courtesy of Don Pino and his family’s strong baseball connection.

With options for dining in, takeaway, or delivery, you can enjoy their seafood offerings anywhere. Favorites include ceviches so fresh they practically swam onto your plate, crispy fish tacos, perfectly grilled lobster, and the show-stopping whole fried fish with all the trimmings. Generous portions and reasonable prices only add to the charm.

Step off the beaten path and let La Justicia de Don Pino transport you to a world of authentic Mexican-Caribbean seafood and a slice of Isla history. It’s a dining experience that hits a culinary home run every time!